← The whole menu

Old-School Squash Casserole

Tender yellow squash and onion in a creamy three-cheese custard under a buttery cracker crust, the Southern church-supper classic.

Adapted from Southern Living (Paige Grandjean)

Serves
8 as a side
Hands-on
25 min
Start to finish
1 hr 5 min
Difficulty
Easy
Make ahead
Assemble without the topping up to 12 hours ahead (or overnight) and refrigerate; add the topping and bake at home on the day.
Vegetarian
Yes

What you are making

Slices of soft yellow squash and onion folded into a creamy mixture of eggs, sour cream, mayonnaise and three cheeses, baked under a crisp, golden layer of buttery crushed crackers. The inside is soft and custardy, just set, with the squash still in recognisable slices; the top crunches. It tastes rich, cheesy and mild, with a little thyme. In the South this is a staple of church suppers and "meat-and-three" diners, and on the Thanksgiving table it is the vegetable side that people go back to for seconds.

What makes this version good

Shopping list

Produce

Dairy and eggs

Pantry

Spices and seasonings

Equipment

Game plan

Steps

  1. Heat the oven and grease the dish. Heat the oven to 350°F. Spray the 11x7 dish with cooking spray.
  2. Prepare the vegetables and cheese. Trim the ends off the squash and slice it into rounds 1/4 inch thick (about the thickness of two stacked coins). Chop the onion. Pull the thyme leaves off the stems and chop them; you need 2 tsp. Shred the cheddar, Swiss and Parmesan, keeping the Parmesan separate.
  3. Sauté the squash. Melt 3 Tbsp of the butter in the large skillet over medium-high heat. Add the squash, onion and 1 tsp of the salt. Cook, stirring often, for about 10 minutes. The pan will fill with liquid as the squash softens, then the liquid will boil away. Keep stirring so it steams rather than browns. It is ready when the liquid is mostly gone and a slice is just tender in the center when you bite it, but still holds its shape and is not floppy or falling apart. Slightly underdone is right.
  4. Drain. Tip everything into the colander set over a bowl and leave it for 5 minutes. A surprising amount of liquid will collect in the bowl. Throw it away.
  5. Mix the filling. In a large bowl, stir together the 2 eggs (beat them lightly first with a fork), the 8 oz sour cream, the cheddar, the Swiss, the 1/2 cup mayonnaise, the 2 tsp thyme, 1/2 tsp pepper and the remaining 1 tsp salt. Add the drained squash and onion and fold it in gently: scoop from the bottom and turn it over, rather than stirring hard, so the slices stay whole.
  6. Fill the dish. Spoon the mixture into the greased dish and spread it level. (If making ahead, cover and refrigerate now, without the topping.)
  7. Make the topping. Put 2 sleeves of crackers in a zip-top bag, press the air out, and crush them with a rolling pin or your hands into coarse crumbs, mostly the size of peas with some bigger pieces. Melt the remaining 3 Tbsp butter in a small microwave-safe bowl on high, about 25 seconds. Toss the crumbs with the melted butter and the shredded Parmesan until evenly coated. Scatter the topping over the casserole.
  8. Bake. Bake until the top is golden brown, about 20 minutes. It is done when the crackers are deep golden, the edges are bubbling, and the middle is set: when you nudge the dish, the center moves as one piece rather than rippling like liquid. If it went in cold from the fridge, it needs longer; the source says to add a few minutes, and the research estimates 30 to 35 minutes in total. Go by the cues.
  9. Rest briefly. Let it sit a few minutes before serving so the filling firms up a little.

Getting it to Carson's

Bake it at home just before you leave, so you do not need Carson's oven, which will be full. Cover the dish loosely with foil (tight foil traps steam and softens the crackers), wrap it in a towel, and carry it flat. It needs nothing at the host's house; serve it warm. Baking it at Carson's is possible (assemble at home, carry the topping in a separate bag, and bake at 350°F as in step 8), but only do that if Carson confirms there is oven space.

If something goes wrong

Changes from the original