- Serves
- 10 as a side
- Hands-on
- 25 min
- Start to finish
- 1 hr 10 min
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Make ahead
- Best made and baked on the day; it can be assembled the day before and baked after it comes back to room temperature.
- Vegetarian
- Yes
What you are making
A baked macaroni and cheese in the creamy "béchamel" style. You make a white sauce on the stove from butter, flour, milk and cream, melt cheddar into it, stir in the pasta and cubes of cheese, and bake it until bubbling, then brown the top under the broiler. It comes out saucy and spoonable, not firm: you serve it with a spoon, and it will not hold a square shape. This is a different dish from the other mac and cheese on the menu (Divas Can Cook), which is the egg-set custard kind that cuts into squares. On the plate it is one of the rich, savory sides next to the turkey.
What makes this version good
- The sauce is seasoned, not just cheesy. Grated onion, dry mustard, nutmeg, cayenne and Worcestershire sauce go in. You will not taste any one of them, but the sauce tastes savory and full rather than of plain milk and cheese.
- The flour and butter are cooked until golden before the milk goes in, which takes away the raw flour taste and gives the sauce a slightly nutty flavor.
- The cheese is stirred in off the heat. Too much heat makes cheese sauce grainy and oily. Taking the pan off the burner first is the simplest way to avoid that.
- Cubes of cheddar are mixed in with the pasta and melt in the oven into gooey pockets.
- The pasta is boiled for only 4 to 5 minutes, because it finishes cooking in the sauce in the oven and would go soft otherwise.
Shopping list
Produce
- 1 small yellow onion. You need 1/3 cup grated.
Dairy and eggs
- 6 Tbsp salted butter (3/4 of a stick) (you may have this)
- 3 1/2 cups milk. Whole milk is the usual choice.
- 1 pint (2 cups) heavy cream. You need 1 3/4 cups.
- 8 oz block extra-sharp yellow (orange) cheddar cheese
- 8 oz block sharp white cheddar cheese
- Buy blocks, not bags of shredded cheese. See step 1 for why.
Pantry
- 16 oz box large elbow macaroni. Large shells or cavatappi (corkscrew-shaped tubes) also work.
- All-purpose flour, 6 Tbsp (you may have this)
- Worcestershire sauce, 2 tsp. A thin, dark, savory sauce in a small bottle, near the steak sauces or ketchup.
- Cooking spray or a little extra butter, for greasing the dish (you may have this)
Spices and seasonings
- Dry mustard, 2 tsp. Sold in the spice aisle as "ground mustard" or "dry mustard"; it is a yellow powder, not the mustard in a jar.
- Kosher salt, 1 tsp, plus more for the pasta water (you may have this)
- Black pepper, 1/4 tsp (you may have this)
- Nutmeg, 1/8 tsp, freshly grated from a whole nutmeg if you can; ground nutmeg is fine.
- Cayenne pepper, 1/8 tsp
Equipment
- 13x9-inch (3-quart) baking dish. If it is glass, check whether the maker says it is safe under the broiler (see step 11).
- Rimmed baking sheet to set the dish on in the oven, to catch drips
- Large pot for the pasta, and a colander
- Large, heavy saucepan or Dutch oven for the sauce, at least 5 quarts, since the pasta gets stirred into it
- Whisk and a heatproof spoon or spatula
- Box grater: large holes for cheese, small holes for the onion
- Measuring cups and spoons
- Oven mitts and a wire rack, if you have one, for cooling
Game plan
- The day before (optional): shop, shred and dice the cheese, and keep it covered in the fridge.
- On the day, about 1 hr 30 min before you leave: take the milk and cream out of the fridge so they lose their chill. Heat the oven, boil the pasta, make the sauce. Allow 25 minutes of active work.
- About 1 hr before you leave: the dish goes in the oven for 30 minutes, then a 2-minute broil.
- About 20 min before you leave: it comes out and rests 15 minutes. Cover and go.
- Assembling ahead instead: the source says you can assemble it a day ahead, cover and refrigerate, and bring it back to room temperature before baking. Same-day is better for this style, because the pasta keeps soaking up sauce as it sits.
Steps
- Prepare the cheese and onion. Cut each 8 oz cheddar block in half. Shred one half of each block on the large holes of the grater (about 1 cup of each), and cut the other half of each into small cubes about 1/2 inch across (about 1 cup of each). Keep the shredded and cubed cheese in separate bowls. Grate the onion on the small holes until you have 1/3 cup of wet pulp and juice; use it all. Shred your own cheese from blocks: bagged shreds are coated with an anti-clumping powder that stops them melting smoothly and is a common cause of grainy sauce.
- Heat the oven. Heat the oven to 350°F. Lightly grease the 13x9 dish with cooking spray or butter.
- Boil the pasta. Bring a large pot of water to a rolling boil and salt it so it tastes noticeably salty. Add the 16 oz pasta and boil for 4 to 5 minutes only, stirring now and then. It will still be quite firm with a chalky center; that is right, since it finishes in the oven. Drain it in the colander and set aside.
- Start the sauce. In the large saucepan over medium heat, melt the 6 Tbsp butter. Add the grated onion, 2 tsp dry mustard, 1 tsp kosher salt, 1/4 tsp black pepper, 1/8 tsp nutmeg and 1/8 tsp cayenne. Stir for 30 seconds; it will sizzle and smell of onion and spice.
- Cook the flour. Add the 6 Tbsp flour and stir constantly for 2 minutes. It turns into a thick, bubbling paste and darkens slightly to a light golden color, and smells a little toasty. Do not let it go brown.
- Add the milk and cream slowly. Pour in about a cup of the milk while whisking hard. The paste will seize up into a thick lump, then loosen; keep whisking until smooth before adding more. Keep adding the rest of the 3 1/2 cups milk and the 1 3/4 cups cream a little at a time, whisking, until it is all in and there are no lumps. Milk and cream that are not fridge-cold make this smoother and quicker.
- Simmer until slightly thick. Bring the sauce to a boil, whisking every so often and scraping the bottom and corners of the pan so nothing sticks. As soon as it bubbles, lower the heat to medium-low and let it simmer gently, whisking, for 5 minutes. It is ready when it is slightly thickened: it coats the back of a spoon, and a line drawn through the coating with your finger stays clear for a moment. It will still be quite runny, like heavy cream rather than gravy. Stir in the 2 tsp Worcestershire sauce.
- Melt in the cheese, off the heat. This is the step that decides whether the sauce is smooth or grainy.
- Take the pan off the burner completely and turn the burner off. Wait until the sauce stops bubbling.
- Measure out 3/4 cup of each shredded cheddar. Keep the remaining 1/4 cup of each shredded cheddar for the top.
- Add the shredded cheese a handful at a time, stirring gently until each handful has melted before adding the next.
- Do not put the pan back on the heat, and do not let the sauce boil once cheese is in it. Boiling or high heat makes the cheese proteins clump into grains and squeeze out oil.
- The finished sauce should be smooth, glossy and pale orange, with no visible specks of cheese. If a few shreds are slow to melt, keep stirring off the heat for another minute; the heat in the sauce will finish them.
- Combine and fill the dish. Stir the drained pasta and all of the cubed cheese into the sauce. It will look very loose and soupy, with lots of sauce around the pasta. That is right: the pasta soaks much of it up in the oven. Pour it into the greased dish and spread it level.
- Bake. Set the dish on the rimmed baking sheet and bake for 30 minutes, until the sauce is bubbling all over, including in the middle, and the top is turning golden.
- Broil the top. Take it out and switch the oven to broil. Check that a rack is about 6 inches below the broiler element. Sprinkle the reserved 1/4 cup of each shredded cheddar over the top. Broil for about 2 minutes, watching the whole time with the door slightly open if your oven allows: you want the cheese melted and golden with a few brown spots, and it can burn in less than a minute past that. If your dish is glass and not marked as broiler-safe, skip the broiler and scatter the reserved cheese over the top as soon as the dish comes out of the oven; it will melt from the heat underneath.
- Rest. Let it cool on a wire rack (or a folded towel) for about 15 minutes. The sauce thickens as it rests and it becomes easier to serve.
Getting it to Carson's
Bake it at home just before you leave. After the 15-minute rest, cover the dish tightly with foil, wrap it in a couple of towels and carry it flat. It needs nothing at the host's house: no oven, no burner. Expect it to be thicker and less saucy than when it came out of the oven; this style tightens as it sits, which is normal. Serve it warm, with a large spoon. Leftovers keep up to 4 days in the fridge; the source reheats single portions on the stove with a splash of milk or cream stirred in, or in the microwave in 30-second bursts.
If something goes wrong
- The sauce is lumpy after adding the milk. The milk went in too fast. Keep whisking hard over medium-low heat; most lumps whisk out. If some remain, pour the sauce through a sieve before adding the cheese.
- The sauce is grainy or oily after adding the cheese. It was too hot, or the cheese was pre-shredded. Off the heat, whisk in a splash of cold milk or cream, which can smooth a slightly grainy sauce; a badly split one will not fully recover, but it will still taste good once baked.
- The sauce never thickened. It was not simmered long enough. Keep it at a gentle simmer, whisking, a few minutes more until it coats a spoon, before you add any cheese.
- The top burned under the broiler. Scrape off the blackest bits; the rest is fine. Next time, stay in front of the oven for the whole broil.
- It is dry when served. It sat a long time or the pasta was boiled too long. Serve with a little warm milk or cream stirred through the portion you scoop.
Changes from the original
- Cheese added in handfuls, and "wait until it stops bubbling". The source says to take the pan off the heat and stir in the cheese until melted. We add the cheese a handful at a time and wait for the bubbling to stop first, to make the anti-graininess step more specific for a beginner. Quantities are unchanged.
- No broiler for glass dishes that are not broiler-safe. The source broils without mentioning the dish. We add the fallback of letting the reserved cheese melt on top from the dish's own heat.
- Otherwise none. The make-ahead option comes from the source's own note.