- Serves
- 12 to 14 as a side
- Hands-on
- 30 min
- Start to finish
- about 2 hr 30 min (1 hr roasting and cooling, 1 hr baking, 15 min rest)
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Make ahead
- Make the topping up to 2 days ahead and roast the potatoes up to 3 days ahead; bake on the day at home.
- Vegetarian
- Yes
What you are making
A baked casserole of smooth, puréed sweet potato, set with eggs so it holds together like a soft pudding, under a thin crust of brown sugar, butter and pecans that melts and hardens into something like pecan candy. The filling itself is only lightly sweet, with lemon and salt so it tastes of sweet potato; the sweetness is concentrated in the crunchy top. This is not the same as the candied yams also on the menu: those are slices of sweet potato baked in a very sweet spiced butter syrup, soft and glossy, with no eggs, no purée and no nuts. On the Thanksgiving plate this is the sweet side that people eat alongside turkey and gravy, not a dessert.
What makes this version good
- The potatoes are roasted whole, not boiled. Roasting drives off water and browns the natural sugars, so the purée tastes deeper and is less watery than boiled potato. (This is our change; see the end.)
- The topping is properly candied. It is only brown sugar, cold butter and pecans, with no flour, so it melts in the oven and sets into a crackly crust instead of a soft crumble.
- Cold butter in small pieces makes the crispest topping. Melted or soft butter gives a greasier, softer top.
- The filling is barely sweetened (3 Tbsp maple syrup for 5 lb of potatoes) and has lemon juice and a full measure of salt, so it does not taste one-note sweet next to the topping.
- The potatoes are puréed in a food processor, which makes the filling silky.
Shopping list
Produce
- 5 lb sweet potatoes with reddish or copper skin and orange flesh. US stores often label these "Garnet" or "Jewel", and sometimes call them "yams"; they are the same thing for this recipe. Do not buy pale-skinned white sweet potatoes or true yams (rough, bark-like skin, white flesh, usually in international markets). Choose potatoes of similar size so they roast in the same time.
- 1 lemon. You need 1 Tbsp juice.
Dairy and eggs
- 4 Tbsp (1/2 stick) unsalted butter, plus a little more for the dish
- 4 large eggs
Pantry
- 1 cup light brown sugar (you may have this)
- 1 cup chopped pecans. A 4 oz bag of chopped pecans or pecan pieces is about 1 cup; they are in the baking aisle.
- 3 Tbsp pure maple syrup. It must say "pure maple syrup"; "pancake syrup" is flavored corn syrup and is not the same.
- 2 Tbsp vanilla extract. Look for "pure vanilla extract"; a 2 oz bottle holds 4 Tbsp.
Spices and seasonings
- Kosher salt: 2 tsp if it is Diamond Crystal (red box), or 1 1/4 tsp if it is Morton (blue box) (you may have this). The two brands are different densities, which is why the amounts differ. If you use the boiling fallback, you also need more salt for the water.
Other
- Foil, for lining the baking sheet
Equipment
- 13x9-inch baking dish
- Rimmed baking sheet, lined with foil (sweet potatoes drip sticky syrup as they roast)
- Food processor. Without one, use a potato masher; the casserole will be slightly coarser, which the source says is fine.
- Fork, small sharp knife, spoon for scooping
- Large mixing bowl, small bowl, whisk, rubber spatula
- Oven mitts
Game plan
- Up to 3 days ahead: roast the sweet potatoes, scoop out the flesh, and refrigerate it in an airtight container.
- Up to 2 days ahead: mix the topping and keep it covered in the fridge.
- On the day, about 2 hr 30 min before you leave (if you did nothing ahead): roast the potatoes (45 min to 1 hr), cool them (about 20 min), purée and assemble (15 min).
- About 1 hr 15 min before you leave: the casserole goes in the oven for 50 to 60 minutes.
- About 15 min before you leave: it comes out and cools 15 minutes. Cover and go.
Steps
- Heat the oven to 400°F for roasting. Put a rack in the middle. Line the rimmed baking sheet with foil.
- Prepare the potatoes. Scrub the 5 lb sweet potatoes under running water and dry them. Do not peel them. Stab each one 4 or 5 times all over with a fork so steam can escape. Lay them on the foil-lined sheet with space between them.
- Roast until completely soft. Roast for about 45 minutes to 1 hour, depending on size. Start checking at 45 minutes. They are done when a small knife slides into the thickest part of the biggest potato with no resistance at all, the skin looks wrinkled and slightly puffed away from the flesh, and the potato gives easily when you squeeze it with an oven mitt. Dark, bubbling syrup leaking onto the foil is normal and a good sign. If the knife meets any firmness in the center, give them 10 minutes more; underdone potato will not purée smoothly.
- Cool them and turn the oven down. Move the potatoes to a plate or board and leave them until cool enough to handle, about 20 minutes. Turn the oven down to 350°F.
- Make the topping while they cool. Cut the 4 Tbsp butter straight from the fridge into small pieces, about 1/4 inch. In a small bowl, mix the butter pieces, 1 cup packed light brown sugar and 1 cup chopped pecans with your fingers or a spoon so the butter is coated in sugar but still in separate little pieces. Do not melt or soften the butter. Cover and put the bowl in the fridge until you need it.
- Butter the dish. Rub the inside of the 13x9 dish with a thin coat of butter.
- Peel and purée. Slit each potato open and scoop the orange flesh into the food processor, leaving the skins behind (they peel off easily once roasted). Throw away the skins and any hard, dark bits from the ends. Process until completely smooth, with no strings or lumps, scraping down the sides once or twice. Work in two or three batches if it does not all fit; the bowl should be no more than about two-thirds full.
- Mix the filling. In a large bowl, whisk the 4 eggs, 3 Tbsp maple syrup, 2 Tbsp vanilla, 1 Tbsp lemon juice and the salt until the mixture is an even color with no streaks of egg white. Scrape in all the sweet potato purée and mix with the rubber spatula until it is one even orange color with no streaks.
- Fill the dish and top it. Spread the filling into the buttered dish, pushing it right into the corners, and smooth the top. Sprinkle the cold topping evenly over the whole surface, breaking up any clumps.
- Bake. Bake at 350°F for 50 to 60 minutes. It is done when the topping is bubbling across the whole surface, including the middle, and has turned a deep golden brown, and the filling is set: when you gently nudge the dish, the middle no longer ripples like a liquid and moves as one piece. If the purée went in cold from the fridge, expect the longer end of the time.
- Cool. Let it cool for 15 minutes before serving or covering. The topping hardens into its crust as it cools.
Fallback: boiling, the published method. If you cannot roast, peel the 5 lb sweet potatoes and cut them into 1 1/2-inch chunks. Boil them in a large pot of salted water until very tender, 12 to 15 minutes; a fork should slide in and the pieces should start to break apart. Drain in a colander and leave 15 minutes to steam off water and cool. Then carry on from step 7, puréeing the chunks. Heat the oven straight to 350°F in this case.
Getting it to Carson's
This travels well. Bake it at home shortly before you leave and let it cool the 15 minutes, then cover the dish with foil (tent it slightly so the foil does not press into the topping), wrap it in a towel and carry it flat. It needs nothing at the host's house: no oven, no microwave. It is good warm or at room temperature, and the candied top stays crisp, unlike a marshmallow topping.
If something goes wrong
- The purée is stringy or lumpy. The potatoes were underdone, or it needs more processing. Process longer; if it is still lumpy, the potatoes needed more roasting time.
- The topping is soft and pale rather than crisp. It came out too early, or the butter was soft when mixed. Bake until the topping is bubbling everywhere and deep golden; keep the topping cold until it goes on.
- The topping is browning too dark before the middle is set. Lay a sheet of foil loosely over the top for the rest of the bake.
- The middle is still loose at 60 minutes. Common if the purée was cold. Keep baking and check every 5 minutes.
- The potatoes are taking much longer than an hour to roast. They are large. Keep going until the knife test passes; there is no harm in extra time.
Changes from the original
- Roasted instead of boiled potatoes. The published recipe peels, cubes and boils the potatoes. The research and the lead review recommend roasting them whole for deeper flavor and a less watery filling. The roasting method (pierce, roast at 400°F about 45 minutes or until tender, cool about 20 minutes) follows Dash of Jazz's sweet potato casserole; we allow up to 1 hour because 5 lb of whole potatoes are often large. Boiling is kept above as the fallback.
- Pecans doubled, from 1/2 cup to 1 cup. The research found the published 1/2 cup makes a very thin crust over a 13x9 dish and recommended 1 cup. The brown sugar and butter are unchanged.
- Make-ahead for roasted potatoes. The source says boiled potatoes can be cooked up to 3 days ahead and refrigerated airtight. We apply the same window to the roasted, scooped flesh.