- Serves
- 12 as a side (doubled batch, 9x13 dish); the published recipe serves 6 in a 9x9
- Hands-on
- 25 min
- Start to finish
- about 1 hr 20 min (doubled batch, including the rest)
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Make ahead
- Bake at home on the day, within an hour or two of leaving; it is not meant to be assembled the night before.
- Vegetarian
- Yes
What you are making
A baked macaroni and cheese in the Southern "custard" style. Cooked pasta is mixed with milk, cream, three cheeses and raw eggs, and baked. The eggs set the liquid like a savory custard, so it comes out firm enough to cut into squares, soft and creamy inside, with browned, slightly crisp smoky cheese on top and at the edges. It is a different dish from the other mac and cheese on the menu (the Southern Living one), which is the saucy, spoonable kind made with a flour-thickened white sauce. On the Thanksgiving plate it sits next to the turkey and dressing as one of the rich, savory sides.
What makes this version good
- You season the mixture before the eggs go in. The cheese and milk are tasted and salted until they taste good on their own. This is what stops baked mac and cheese from being bland, and it is safe to taste because there is no raw egg in it yet.
- Smoked cheddar on top. It browns into a smoky crust that most versions do not have.
- A little Velveeta. Processed cheese melts smoothly without separating, so the inside stays creamy without making a stovetop cheese sauce. There is no sauce to split or turn grainy.
- The pasta goes in slightly underdone and the dish comes out of the oven while the middle still wobbles. Both stop it drying out, because the pasta keeps softening and the custard keeps setting after it leaves the oven.
Shopping list
Quantities are for a doubled batch (12 servings, 9x13 dish), which is what we want for about 10 people. The original single batch is shown in brackets. If you make a single batch, use a 9x9 dish.
Dairy and eggs
- 3 cups whole milk [single: 1 1/2 cups]
- 1 cup heavy whipping cream [single: 1/2 cup]. Sold in small cartons near the milk; "heavy cream" is the same thing.
- 8 oz block Colby Jack cheese, to give 2 cups shredded [single: 1 cup]. Colby Jack is a mild orange-and-white marbled cheese.
- 8 oz block sharp cheddar cheese, to give 2 cups shredded [single: 1 cup]
- 8 oz smoked cheddar cheese, to give 2 cups shredded [single: 1 cup]. Usually in the specialty or deli cheese case rather than the main cheese aisle. If you cannot find it, smoked gouda is what cooks use instead.
- One 16 oz block Velveeta [use 12 to 16 oz; single: 6 to 8 oz]. A soft processed cheese sold as a block in a box. Stores often shelve it unrefrigerated near the boxed macaroni and cheese rather than in the dairy case. Use less if you want it less creamy.
- 4 large eggs [single: 2]
- Butter, a little for greasing the dish (you may have this)
Pantry
- Two 16 oz boxes elbow macaroni (you will use 6 cups dry, about 1 1/2 lb) [single: 3 cups]
Spices and seasonings
- Seasoned salt, such as Lawry's, or plain salt (you may have this). Seasoned salt is a salt blend with paprika, garlic and onion; it is in the spice aisle.
- Black pepper (you may have this)
- Plain salt for the pasta water (you may have this)
- Optional: onion powder, garlic powder, dry mustard powder
- Optional: smoked paprika, for sprinkling on top
Equipment
- 9x13-inch baking dish, glass or ceramic, at least 2 inches deep (9x9-inch for a single batch)
- Large pot for boiling pasta, and a colander
- Box grater for the cheese
- Large mixing bowl and a spoon or whisk
- Oven mitts
- Foil and a couple of towels for carrying
Game plan
- The day before: shop. If you want to save time, shred all the cheese and keep it covered in the fridge.
- On the day, about 1 hr 30 min before you leave: take the eggs out of the fridge so they are not fridge-cold. Heat the oven and boil the pasta.
- About 1 hr 10 min before you leave: the dish goes in the oven. It bakes 35 to 45 minutes for a single batch, longer for a doubled one.
- About 15 min before you leave: it comes out and rests. Wrap it and go.
Steps
- Heat the oven and grease the dish. Heat the oven to 350°F. Rub the inside of the 9x13 dish with a thin coat of butter.
- Shred the cheese. Shred the Colby Jack, sharp cheddar and smoked cheddar on the large holes of a box grater, keeping the smoked cheddar in its own pile. Shred the Velveeta too, or cut it into very small cubes (it is soft, so cubes are easier). Shred from blocks rather than buying bags of pre-shredded cheese: bagged shreds are coated with an anti-clumping powder and do not melt as smoothly.
- Boil the pasta. Bring a large pot of water to a rolling boil and salt it well, so it tastes noticeably salty. Add the 6 cups macaroni and stir so it does not stick. Cook until slightly less than al dente. Start tasting a piece a few minutes before the shortest time on the box: it is ready when it bends easily but still has a firm, chewy center and a faint white dot in the middle when you bite it. It finishes cooking in the oven, so if you cook it fully now it will turn soft and mushy.
- Drain. Pour the pasta into the colander and shake it well so no water is left pooled in the elbows. Set aside.
- Mix the custard base. In a large bowl, stir together the 3 cups milk, 1 cup cream, the 2 cups Colby Jack, the Velveeta and the 2 cups sharp cheddar. It will look like cold milk with shreds of cheese floating in it. That is right; the cheese melts in the oven.
- Season it, and taste. This is the step that matters most. Add about 2 teaspoons seasoned salt (or plain salt) and 1 teaspoon black pepper (half that for a single batch), plus a pinch of onion, garlic or mustard powder if you like. Stir and taste a spoonful. It should taste clearly seasoned on its own, like a good cheese sauce, a little saltier than you think you need, because the pasta will soak some of it up. If it tastes flat or mostly of milk, add more seasoned salt a little at a time, stirring and tasting each time.
- Add the eggs. Only once you are happy with the taste, crack in the 4 eggs and stir until no streaks of yolk or white remain. Do not taste it after this.
- Combine in the dish. Tip the drained macaroni into the buttered dish. Pour the cheese mixture over it evenly, then stir gently so the cheese and liquid are spread through the pasta. The liquid should come up around the pasta, with the top layer of macaroni just poking out.
- Top it. Scatter all 2 cups of smoked cheddar thickly over the top, right to the edges. Sprinkle lightly with smoked paprika and/or black pepper if you want color.
- Bake. Put the dish in the middle of the oven. A single batch takes 35 to 45 minutes. A doubled batch in a 9x13 is deeper and may need longer than 45 minutes; start checking at 35 and then every 5 minutes. It is done when the top is melted and golden with browned spots, the edges are set and pulling slightly from the dish, and the middle still wobbles a little when you gently shake the dish with oven mitts, like a set jelly rather than a liquid. If liquid sloshes in the middle, it needs more time. Do not wait for the middle to be firm: it sets as it cools, and overbaking is what makes this dry.
- Rest. Let it sit on the counter for 10 to 15 minutes before cutting or carrying. It firms up during this time while staying creamy inside.
Getting it to Carson's
This travels well because it sets into one block and does not slosh. Bake it at home so it comes out of the oven within an hour or two of leaving. After the rest, cover the dish tightly with foil, wrap it in a couple of towels, and carry it flat (on the floor of the car, not on a seat). It needs nothing at the host's house: no oven, no burner. Serve it warm, cut into squares or scooped with a large spoon. Leftovers keep 3 to 4 days in the fridge, covered.
If something goes wrong
- It tastes bland. The seasoning step was too light. At the table, a sprinkle of salt or seasoned salt helps. Next time, taste the base before adding the eggs and keep adding seasoned salt until it tastes good on its own.
- It is dry or greasy. It was overbaked. Take it out while the middle still wobbles; it carries on setting as it rests.
- The middle is still liquid after the rest. It came out too early. Put it back in at 350°F for another 5 to 10 minutes and check the wobble again.
- The pasta is mushy. It was boiled too long. Pull it while it is still firm in the center; it softens a lot in the oven.
- The top is browning too fast before the middle sets. Lay a sheet of foil loosely over the top for the rest of the bake.
Changes from the original
- Doubled for a 9x13 dish. The published recipe makes 6 servings in a 9x9. The lead review asked for it to be doubled for about 10 people. The source's FAQ says it can be doubled and to judge doneness by the set edges and wobbly middle rather than the clock, because the pan is deeper. The source gives no baking time for the doubled batch.
- A starting amount of seasoning. The source says only "to taste". We give a starting point (about 2 teaspoons seasoned salt and 1 teaspoon pepper for the doubled batch) from the research assessment, then you taste and adjust, because a cook who has never eaten this dish has nothing to taste against.