- Serves
- 10 to 12 as a starter (36 halves, three times the recipe)
- Hands-on
- 45 min
- Start to finish
- about 1 hr 15 min, including cooling
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Make ahead
- Cook the eggs and make the filling up to about 24 hours ahead, stored separately; fill on the day.
- Vegetarian
- Yes
What you are making
Deviled eggs are hard-cooked eggs cut in half lengthwise, with the yolks scooped out, mashed with mayonnaise and seasonings, and spooned back into the whites. "Deviled" just means spiced. They are eaten cold, in one or two bites, as a starter while people wait for dinner. The filling should be smooth, creamy and pale yellow, tangy from mustard and pickle relish, with a light kick of hot sauce. Every Southern holiday table has a plate of them.
What makes this version good
- Steamed, not boiled. Cooking the eggs in steam makes the shells come away cleanly, so the whites stay smooth instead of torn. Peeling is where most first attempts go wrong.
- A test egg. You cook one extra egg and open it at 12 minutes, so you know your timing before you cool the whole batch.
- Vinegar hot sauce and garlic powder add a background tang and depth beyond plain mayonnaise and mustard.
Shopping list
Dairy and eggs
- 2 dozen large eggs (you cook 18 plus a test egg; the rest are spares in case some crack or peel badly)
Pantry
- 9 Tbsp mayonnaise (½ cup plus 1 Tbsp; Duke's is the traditional Southern brand, Hellmann's is fine)
- 4½ tsp yellow mustard (1½ Tbsp; the bright yellow American kind, such as French's)
- Vinegar-based hot sauce, such as Texas Pete, Crystal or Tabasco (you need 6 dashes)
- 4½ Tbsp pickle relish, sweet or dill (¼ cup plus 1½ tsp; one jar). Sweet relish is the more common Southern choice; Stacey prefers dill. Pick the one you like.
Spices and seasonings
- ¾ tsp garlic powder (you may have this)
- Salt and black pepper (you may have these)
- Paprika, for sprinkling on top (optional; spice aisle; sweet, not smoked)
Other
- 1 bag ice, or several trays from your freezer, for the ice bath
- Gallon-size zip-top bags, for carrying and piping the filling
Equipment
- Large wide pot with a tight-fitting lid, or a medium saucepan with a lid and cook in batches. The recipe uses a medium saucepan for 6 eggs; 19 eggs need either a wide pot where they sit in one layer, or two or three batches.
- Steamer basket that fits the pot (optional; the eggs can sit straight on the bottom of the pan)
- Large bowl for the ice bath
- Slotted spoon or tongs
- Sharp knife, a fork and a medium bowl
- Airtight containers and a serving platter (a deviled-egg plate with little hollows helps but is not needed)
Game plan
- The day before (up to about 24 hours ahead): Cook, cool and peel the eggs. Halve them, make the filling, and store the whites and filling separately in the fridge. About 1 hour.
- At Carson's, just before serving: Pipe the filling into the whites. About 10 minutes.
Steps
This guide makes three times the recipe (18 eggs, 36 halves). For the original single batch, use 6 eggs and a third of each filling amount: 3 Tbsp mayonnaise, 1½ tsp mustard, 2 dashes hot sauce, ¼ tsp garlic powder and 1½ Tbsp relish.
- Set up the steam. Pour about ½ inch of water into the pot and put in the steamer basket if using. Cover and bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Turn the heat off.
- Add the eggs. Using a spoon or tongs, gently lower 18 eggs plus 1 test egg into the basket or onto the bottom of the pot. Cover, turn the heat back to medium-high and bring back to a boil. If they do not all fit in one layer, cook them in batches with a test egg in each, topping up the water to ½ inch between batches.
- Steam. Once the water is boiling again, steam for 12 to 15 minutes with the lid on. Meanwhile, fill the large bowl with ice and cold water.
- Check the test egg. At 12 minutes, take out the test egg, cool it under cold water until you can handle it, peel it and cut it in half. The yolk should be fully set, pale yellow and crumbly all the way to the center. If the center is still dark orange and soft or sticky, steam the rest for another minute or two (no more than 15 minutes in total). A gray-green ring around the yolk means it went too long; it is safe to eat but does not look as good.
- Ice bath. Move the eggs straight into the ice water and leave them until they are completely cold all the way through: pick one up, and it should feel cold, with no warmth coming from the middle. Add more ice if it melts.
- Peel. Tap each egg all over on the counter to crack the shell, then peel it, starting from the wide end where there is a small air pocket. Peeling under a thin stream of cold water helps. Rinse off any bits of shell.
- Halve and scoop. Cut each egg in half lengthwise, from tip to tip. Gently pop the yolks out with a small spoon or your thumb into the medium bowl. Lay the whites on a plate, hollow side up.
- Make the filling. Mash the yolks with a fork until they are fine crumbs with no big lumps. Add 9 Tbsp mayonnaise, 4½ tsp yellow mustard, 6 dashes hot sauce and ¾ tsp garlic powder and mix until smooth and creamy, like thick frosting. Stir in 4½ Tbsp pickle relish. Season with salt and pepper, tasting as you go: it should be tangy and well seasoned, not bland.
- Store (if making ahead). Spoon the filling into a zip-top bag, press out the air and seal. Put the whites in an airtight container. Refrigerate both. Keep them apart until serving, or the whites go soggy.
- Fill. Push the filling down into one bottom corner of the bag, snip off a small piece of the corner, and squeeze the filling into each white, mounding it up a little. Or simply spoon it in, as Stacey does. Sprinkle with black pepper or paprika.
Getting it to Carson's
- Carry the container of whites and the bag of filling in a cooler bag with ice packs, or straight from the fridge if the trip is short.
- At the house, fill them on the platter (step 10). It needs no oven, burner or microwave, only about 10 minutes of counter space and a place in the fridge until serving.
- Deviled eggs should not sit out at room temperature for more than 2 hours (standard US food-safety guidance for egg and mayonnaise dishes). Put any left over back in the fridge.
If something goes wrong
- The shells stick and the whites tear. Peel under running water and get your thumb under the thin skin just inside the shell, not only the hard shell. Torn halves can still be filled; put the best ones on top.
- The yolks are soft in the middle. They were not cooked long enough. Mash them anyway; slightly soft yolks still make a filling, but next time steam a minute or two longer.
- The filling is too stiff. Add a little more mayonnaise, a small spoonful at a time.
- The filling is too runny. It has too much mayonnaise or relish liquid. Chill it in the fridge; it firms up as it gets cold. Next time add the relish with less of its liquid.
- The eggs slide around on the platter. Cut a very thin slice off the rounded underside of each white so it sits flat.
Changes from the original
- Made three times bigger. The recipe makes 6 eggs (12 halves), which is too few for a party of 10; the guide uses 18 eggs and triples every filling amount. Cooking in batches is suggested because 19 eggs do not fit in a medium saucepan.
- Fill at the host's. Stacey says to store the filling and whites separately for about 24 hours and fill on the day; the guide applies that to carrying them, using her zip-top bag piping method.
- Peeling and troubleshooting tips added. The recipe gives no peeling method beyond steaming.
- Ice bath and cooling time described. The recipe says only "until completely cool".