- Serves
- 10 as a side
- Hands-on
- 30 min (plus 10 min to mix the cornbread)
- Start to finish
- about 2 hr on the day, plus baking the cornbread 1 to 2 days ahead
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Make ahead
- Bake the cornbread 1 to 2 days ahead; bake the dressing on the day and carry it hot, or bake it up to 4 days ahead and reheat.
What you are making
Dressing (also called stuffing) is a savory baked bread dish served next to the turkey, usually with gravy over it. This is the Black Southern home version: unsweetened cornbread (a crumbly bread made from ground corn) is crumbled, mixed with soft-cooked onion, celery and green bell pepper, shredded chicken, broth, sage and black pepper, then bound with eggs and baked. It goes into the oven wet, like thick porridge, and comes out moist and soft but set enough to hold its shape when cut, golden on top. It should taste savory, peppery and of sage, like a well-seasoned chicken soup turned into bread.
What makes this version good
- Dried cornbread. Day-old cornbread, toasted in the oven, soaks up the broth without turning to paste.
- Unsweetened cornbread. The cornbread here has no sugar. Sweet cornbread makes the dressing taste sweet, which is wrong for this dish.
- Broth added a little at a time. Every batch of cornbread drinks a different amount, so you add broth until it looks right rather than pouring in a fixed amount.
- You taste before the eggs go in. Everything in the bowl is cooked and safe to eat at that point, so you can season it until it tastes exactly right. Once the raw eggs go in, you cannot taste again.
Shopping list
Produce
- 1 large yellow onion (you need half, 1 cup diced)
- 1 bunch celery (you need about 3 stalks, 1 cup diced)
- 1 medium green bell pepper (1 cup diced). You can use half green and half red bell pepper; Monique's grandmother sometimes does.
Meat
- 1 rotisserie chicken (a whole cooked chicken sold hot or chilled at the supermarket deli). You need the meat from 1 breast; use the thigh meat as well if you like, since Monique says thighs give more flavor.
Dairy and eggs
- 4 large eggs (2 for the cornbread, 2 for the dressing)
- 1 pint buttermilk (you need ¾ cup; dairy case, near the milk)
- 1 stick unsalted butter (for cooking the vegetables and greasing the dish)
Pantry
- Self-rising cornmeal mix, such as Martha White or White Lily "Self-Rising White Cornmeal Mix" (baking aisle, near the flour). You need 1 cup. The label must say "self-rising"; plain cornmeal will not rise. Do not use Jiffy or any "corn muffin" or honey cornbread mix: they are sweet.
- Self-rising flour, such as White Lily or Gold Medal Self-Rising (you need ½ cup)
- 2 Tbsp vegetable oil, plus a little for greasing (you may have this)
- 1 loaf plain white sandwich bread (you need 3 slices; potato bread or butter bread also works)
- 2 cartons (32 oz each) chicken broth, regular rather than low-sodium (you need 3 to 4 cups; the rest is for reheating). Or 1 jar Better Than Bouillon Roasted Chicken Base, mixed with water as the label says; Monique uses this paste. Never the beef flavor.
Spices and seasonings
- Poultry seasoning, 1 jar (you need 1 tsp, and maybe more after tasting; a ground herb blend of sage, thyme and similar herbs; spice aisle; contains no meat)
- Ground or rubbed sage, 1 jar (you need 1 tsp, and maybe more after tasting; dried sage; spice aisle)
- 1 tsp black pepper (you may have this)
- Salt (you may have this)
Other
- Aluminum foil (you may have this)
- Plan B cornbread, only if you cannot find self-rising cornmeal mix and self-rising flour: 1¼ cups yellow cornmeal (stone-ground if you can find it), ¾ cup all-purpose flour, 1½ tsp baking powder, ½ tsp baking soda and ¼ tsp salt, plus a second stick of butter (you need 6 Tbsp) and 1 cup buttermilk instead of ¾ cup (the pint covers it). This is the cornbread from Monique's updated 2017 recipe.
Equipment
- 9×9-inch baking pan for the cornbread (8×8-inch for the Plan B cornbread)
- Rimmed baking sheet, for toasting the cornbread
- Large skillet
- Very large mixing bowl and a small bowl
- 13×9-inch baking dish
- Toaster (or toast the bread on the baking sheet)
- Toothpick
Game plan
- 1 to 2 days before: Bake the cornbread (step 1). Once cool, leave it out, uncovered, overnight.
- On the day, about 2½ hours before you leave: Toast the cornbread and bread, cook the vegetables, shred the chicken (steps 2 to 4). About 40 minutes.
- About 1½ hours before you leave: Mix, taste, add the eggs and bake (steps 5 to 8). 45 to 55 minutes in the oven.
- Leave with it hot, wrapped up.
Steps
- Bake the cornbread (1 to 2 days ahead). Heat the oven to 350°F and grease the 9×9-inch pan with a little oil or butter. In a large bowl whisk 1 cup self-rising cornmeal mix and ½ cup self-rising flour. Lightly beat 2 eggs and add them with ¾ cup buttermilk and 2 Tbsp vegetable oil. Stir only until there is no dry flour left; a few lumps are fine, and overmixing makes it tough. Pour into the pan. Bake about 20 to 25 minutes, until the top is golden, the edges have pulled away from the pan, and a toothpick pushed into the center comes out clean. Let it cool, then leave it out on the counter, uncovered, overnight so it starts to dry. Use the whole pan in the dressing.
- Plan B cornbread: Heat the oven to 425°F and grease the 8×8-inch pan. Whisk 1¼ cups yellow cornmeal, ¾ cup all-purpose flour, 1½ tsp baking powder, ½ tsp baking soda and ¼ tsp salt. Make a hollow in the middle, add 2 lightly beaten eggs and 1 cup buttermilk, and stir gently just until combined. Stir in 6 Tbsp melted butter. Spread in the pan and bake 20 to 25 minutes, until golden and a toothpick comes out clean. Cool and leave out overnight as above.
- Toast the cornbread and bread. Heat the oven to 325°F. Break the cornbread into rough chunks and crumbs, spread it on the baking sheet and toast it 15 to 20 minutes, stirring once, until the outsides feel dry and the edges are light golden. It should not be hard like a cracker. Toast 3 slices of bread until golden and dry, let them cool, and crumble them into small pieces with your fingers. Put the cornbread and toast crumbs in the very large bowl.
- Cook the vegetables. Dice the onion, celery and bell pepper into small pieces, about ¼ inch, and measure 1 cup of each. Melt 2 Tbsp butter in the skillet over medium heat. Add the vegetables and cook, stirring now and then, until they are completely tender: the onion is soft and see-through, and a piece of celery squashes easily against the pan and has no crunch when you bite it. This takes longer than it looks; undercooked celery stays crunchy in the finished dressing. Do not let them brown. Add them to the bowl.
- Add the chicken. Pull the meat off 1 rotisserie chicken breast (and the thighs, if using), throwing away the skin and bones. Shred it into bite-size pieces with two forks or your fingers. Add it to the bowl and stir everything together gently.
- Add broth until it looks right. Pour in about 1 cup broth and stir gently, then keep adding about a cup at a time, waiting a minute between each for the cornbread to drink it. Stop when the mixture looks like thick, soupy oatmeal: very wet, with liquid you can see between the crumbs, but not swimming. Monique usually needs about 3½ cups; the range is 3 to 4. Do not stir hard or mash it, or it turns pasty.
- Season and taste. Stir in 1 tsp poultry seasoning, 1 tsp sage and 1 tsp black pepper. Taste a spoonful. It should taste like a well-salted, savory soup with a clear taste of sage and pepper. If it tastes flat, add salt a little at a time; if you want more herb flavor, add more poultry seasoning and sage. Monique's grandmother uses far more than 1 teaspoon of each, and her 2017 version uses 1 tablespoon of each. Taste after every addition until you are happy with it.
- Add the eggs. Lightly beat 2 eggs in the small bowl and stir them gently into the mixture. From here on, do not taste it.
- Bake. Heat the oven to 350°F. Butter the 13×9-inch dish well and pour in the dressing, spreading it evenly. One cook's test: lay your hand flat on top and move it gently side to side; the whole thing should jiggle like jelly. Bake 45 to 55 minutes, until it is set: the center no longer looks wet or wobbles like liquid when you shake the dish gently, the edges have pulled away slightly, and the top is golden. If the top is browning before the middle has set, lay a sheet of foil loosely over it. Let it cool for a little while before cutting, so it holds its shape.
Getting it to Carson's
- Best (no oven needed at Carson's): Bake it on the day so it comes out about 30 minutes before you leave. Cover tightly with foil and wrap the dish in a couple of towels. It stays hot for about an hour.
- If you bake it ahead: Cool, cover and refrigerate for up to 4 days. Reheating needs an oven: covered with foil at 325°F until heated right through, with a splash of broth over the top if it looks dry. Oven space at Carson's is short on the day, so choose the first option if you can.
- Bring the extra broth either way.
If something goes wrong
- The cornbread is still soft and cakey after toasting. Toast it longer, checking every 5 minutes, until the outsides feel dry.
- The mix soaked up all the broth and looks dry. Add more, a splash at a time, until it is back to soupy oatmeal. It is better slightly too wet than too dry; dry dressing bakes up crumbly.
- It is too wet, with broth pooling on top. Toast and crumble a little more bread and stir it in.
- The green pepper taste is too strong for you. Several cooks find it overpowering. Next time use half the green pepper, or half green and half red.
- The finished dressing is dry on top or at the edges. Spoon a little warm broth over it, cover with foil and let it sit for a few minutes before serving. Next time cover it with foil for most of the bake.
Changes from the original
- Cornbread drying given a time and temperature. The recipe says to use day-old cornbread and toast it, with no time or temperature. The guide follows our research's cornbread advice: leave it out uncovered overnight, then toast at 325°F for 15 to 20 minutes, until the outsides are dry and the edges light golden.
- Butter for the vegetables measured. The recipe says "a little bit of butter or olive oil" and does not list it. The guide uses 2 Tbsp butter, the amount in Monique's 2017 update.
- Vegetable cooking described by look and feel. The recipe says only "until tender"; the guide gives the signs to look for. No time is given because the source gives none.
- The chicken named. The recipe says "1 cooked chicken breast or cooked chicken thighs" without saying how to cook it. The guide uses the meat from a store-bought rotisserie chicken.
- The broth named. Regular chicken broth, or Better Than Bouillon Roasted Chicken Base, which Monique recommends in her 2017 update, and never beef. Her 2017 tip that the broth should taste salted like soup is included.
- Texture and timing from the 2017 update and readers. "Thick, soupy oatmeal", the 45 to 55 minute bake, optional foil and the storage and reheating instructions all come from Monique's 2017 version of the recipe. The hand-jiggle test comes from a reader's comment. The original says "45 minutes or until set".
- Plan B cornbread from the 2017 update, for cooks who cannot find self-rising cornmeal.
- Author name. The page credits Monique Kilgore.