- Serves
- 8
- Hands-on
- 15 min
- Start to finish
- 1 hr 25 min, plus about 3 hr to cool
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Make ahead
- Bake the day before; it keeps covered at room temperature for up to 2 days.
- Vegetarian
- Yes
What you are making
Chess pie is an old Southern custard pie made from pantry staples: butter, sugar, eggs, buttermilk and a spoonful of cornmeal. There is no fruit or nut in it. The filling bakes into a smooth, rich, very sweet custard, pale yellow inside, with a thin golden-brown top that turns slightly crackly from the cornmeal. Lemon and buttermilk give it a gentle tang. Cut it in thin slices; it is rich. It sits on the dessert table beside the pumpkin and pecan pies.
What makes this version good
- Cornmeal and a little flour set the custard and give the top its slightly crisp, sugary crust.
- Buttermilk and lemon add sourness that keeps a very sweet pie from tasting flat.
- Butter and sugar beaten until fluffy first, so the custard is light rather than dense.
- Everything at room temperature. Cold eggs or buttermilk make the soft butter seize into lumps.
- A pre-baked crust, so the bottom is cooked rather than soggy under the wet filling.
Shopping list
Produce
- 1 lemon (you need 1 teaspoon juice and 1 teaspoon grated zest). A lime works instead.
Dairy and eggs
- 1 stick (1/2 cup) unsalted butter
- 4 large eggs
- 1 small carton buttermilk (you need 1/3 cup). Dairy case, near the milk.
Pantry
- 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar (you may have this)
- 2 tablespoons plain yellow cornmeal. Not "cornbread mix" or "self-rising cornmeal", which have other things added. Baking aisle.
- 1 tablespoon all-purpose flour (you may have this)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract (you may have this)
- 1 bag (1 to 2 lb) dried beans or uncooked rice, to weigh down the crust while it pre-bakes. They can be reused for this purpose but not eaten afterwards.
Spices and seasonings
- 1/4 teaspoon salt (you may have this)
Other
- 1 frozen 9-inch deep-dish pie shell. Freezer section, near the frozen desserts, usually in packs of two in their own foil pans.
- Parchment paper or aluminum foil (for lining the crust), plus foil for covering the pie
Equipment
- Electric mixer: a stand mixer or a hand mixer. The butter and sugar need 3 to 4 minutes of beating, which is hard to do by hand.
- Large mixing bowl and a rubber spatula
- Fine grater (a rasp-style or the smallest holes of a box grater) for the zest
- Fork, for pricking the crust
- Rimmed baking sheet to set the pie on
- Wire cooling rack, or a cold stovetop grate
- If a confident cook wants a homemade crust: Grandbaby Cakes' pie crust, the one the recipe is written for, rolled into a 9-inch pie plate.
Game plan
- The night before you bake: Nothing, unless your butter is very hard; then leave it on the counter overnight.
- Baking day (the day before Thanksgiving is ideal): Set the butter, eggs and buttermilk out on the counter well before you start, so they reach room temperature (see step 1 for how to tell). Pre-bake the shell, mix and bake: about 1 hour 25 minutes. Cool about 3 hours.
- On the day: Carry it at room temperature. Nothing to do at Carson's except slice.
Steps
- Room temperature first. The butter should be soft enough that a finger presses into it easily. The eggs and buttermilk should not feel cold. If the buttermilk is still cold, microwave it for a few seconds at a time until it is no longer chilled; do not make it hot.
- Heat the oven to 350°F with a rack in the center.
- Pre-bake the shell. Set the frozen shell, in its foil pan, on the baking sheet. Let it sit a few minutes until a fork goes in without cracking it. Prick the bottom and sides all over with the fork. Read the box: Jocelyn says to follow the package's pre-baking directions for a frozen crust, so use its temperature and time for an empty (unfilled) shell. Before it goes in, line the shell with parchment or foil and fill it to the top with the dried beans or rice; this stops the bottom puffing up and the sides slumping. If the box gives no pre-bake directions, bake it 10 minutes at 350°F with the weights in, as the recipe does for a homemade crust. When it comes out, lift out the lining and weights together. The bottom should look dry and matte, not wet or shiny. If the package used a hotter oven, set the oven back to 350°F.
- Cream the butter and sugar. In the mixer bowl, beat the 1/2 cup soft butter and 1 1/2 cups sugar on medium speed until light and fluffy, 3 to 4 minutes. It should turn from yellow and gritty to pale, almost white, and look like thick frosting.
- Add the cornmeal and flour. Beat in 2 tablespoons cornmeal and 1 tablespoon flour.
- Add the eggs one at a time. Beat in 1 egg until fully mixed in, stop, and scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl with the spatula. Repeat with each of the 4 eggs.
- Finish the filling. Grate 1 teaspoon zest from the lemon (only the yellow skin, not the white underneath), then squeeze 1 teaspoon juice. Add 1/3 cup room-temperature buttermilk, 1 teaspoon vanilla, the lemon juice, the zest and 1/4 teaspoon salt. Beat until smooth. A few tiny flecks of butter are fine; large lumps mean something was cold (see below).
- Fill and bake. Pour the filling into the pre-baked shell and slide the baking sheet carefully into the oven. Bake 50 to 60 minutes.
- Shield it early. Check the pie after 15 to 20 minutes. Lay a piece of foil loosely over the top so it does not brown too much, and leave it there for the rest of the bake.
- Test for doneness. From 50 minutes, nudge the baking sheet. The pie is done when the edges of the filling are firm and the center wobbles slightly, like set jelly. If the center ripples like liquid, it needs more time; keep baking and check every 5 minutes. If you own an instant-read thermometer, Serious Eats' chess pie recipe gives 180°F in the center as a backup check.
- Cool. Set the pie on the rack and let it come to room temperature, about 3 hours, before slicing. It finishes setting as it cools; cut too early and it will be runny.
Getting it to Carson's
- This is the easiest pie on the menu to carry. Once cool, cover it with foil or plastic wrap. It keeps covered at room temperature in a cool spot for up to 2 days, so no fridge is needed.
- Carry it flat, on the baking sheet or in a box, on the car floor.
- It needs nothing at Carson's: no oven, no fridge. Leave it in its foil pan.
If something goes wrong
- The filling looks curdled before baking. The eggs or buttermilk were cold, and the butter formed small lumps. Let the bowl sit in a warm spot for a few minutes and beat again. Small flecks are fine and bake out.
- The center is still liquid at 60 minutes. Keep baking until it only wobbles. An oven that runs cool makes this pie runny; an oven thermometer will tell you.
- The top cracked. It baked a little too long. It tastes the same.
- The crust edge is getting dark. Keep the foil over the whole pie; Jocelyn also suggests a pie shield or foil ring over the crust.
- The bottom puffed up during pre-baking. There were not enough weights. Press it down gently with the back of a spoon while still hot.
Changes from the original
- Written around a store-bought frozen 9-inch deep-dish shell, which the recipe allows. The pre-bake follows the package, as Jocelyn says, with weights added per our research notes, and the recipe's own 10 minutes at 350°F as a fallback if the box gives no directions.
- The pie bakes on a rimmed baking sheet, which is our addition for a thin foil pan.
- The 180°F thermometer check comes from Serious Eats' chess pie, not this recipe. It is a backup only; the recipe's jiggle test comes first.
- The optional egg wash for a homemade crust is left out.