- Serves
- 8
- Hands-on
- 15 min
- Start to finish
- 1 hr, plus a few hours to cool
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Make ahead
- Bake the day before, cool, cover and refrigerate.
- Vegetarian
- Yes
What you are making
Pumpkin pie is the signature Thanksgiving dessert: a pastry shell filled with a smooth, spiced pumpkin custard, served cold or at room temperature with whipped cream. The filling should be deep orange-brown, smooth and glossy on top with no cracks, and set enough to slice cleanly. It tastes of pumpkin, cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg: sweet, warm-spiced and creamy, a little like a firm, spiced flan.
What makes this version good
- Sweetened condensed milk in place of the usual sugar plus evaporated milk. It is richer and smoother, and it removes a measuring step.
- One whole egg plus three yolks. Chef John swapped egg whites for yolks; the custard is richer and much less likely to crack.
- A pinch of Chinese five-spice adds depth behind the usual pie spices.
- No pre-baking the crust. The filling goes straight into the unbaked shell, which suits a store-bought frozen shell.
- A clear doneness test: a knife pushed in 1 inch from the edge comes out clean.
Shopping list
Dairy and eggs
- 4 large eggs (you need 1 whole egg and 3 yolks)
- Whipped cream for serving (optional). A can of real whipped cream from the dairy case is the easiest.
Pantry
- 1 can (15 oz) pumpkin purée. The label must say "100% pure pumpkin" or "pumpkin purée", not "pumpkin pie filling" or "pumpkin pie mix", which is already sweetened and spiced. Libby's is the common brand; baking aisle.
- 1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk. Thick, sweet, in a small can in the baking aisle. Not evaporated milk, which is in a similar can.
Spices and seasonings
- 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/2 teaspoon ground ginger
- 1/2 teaspoon fine salt (ordinary table salt; you may have this)
- 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg, plus a little for the top. Chef John grates whole nutmeg; ground nutmeg from a jar works.
- 1/8 teaspoon Chinese five-spice powder (spice aisle or Asian aisle). If you cannot find it, use a small pinch each of ground star anise, ground cloves and ground white pepper, as Chef John suggests.
Other
- 1 frozen 9-inch deep-dish pie shell. Freezer section, usually near the frozen desserts, sold in packs of two in their own foil pans. Make sure it says "deep dish". Keep it frozen until baking day.
- Aluminum foil
Equipment
- Large mixing bowl and a whisk
- Small bowl for separating eggs
- Rimmed baking sheet to set the pie on
- Paring knife (small knife) for the doneness test
- Wire cooling rack, or a cold stovetop grate
- If a confident cook wants a homemade crust: King Arthur's Classic Double Pie Crust, fitted into a 9-inch pie plate and crimped. Use one of the two crusts.
Game plan
- Up to a week before: Shop. Keep the shell in the freezer.
- The day before Thanksgiving: Mix, bake and cool. About 1 hour 15 minutes of oven time and handling, then a few hours on the counter until fully cool. Cover and refrigerate overnight.
- On the day: Carry it cold. Nothing to do at Carson's except slice.
Steps
- Heat the oven to 425°F with a rack in the middle.
- Get the shell ready. Read the back of the pie-shell box and follow its directions for a filled, single-crust pie (some brands are filled straight from the freezer, some ask for a short thaw first). Do not pre-bake it; this recipe does not. Set the shell, still in its foil pan, on the baking sheet. The sheet keeps the thin foil pan from bending when you move it, and catches drips.
- Separate the eggs. Crack 3 eggs one at a time over a small bowl. Pass the yolk back and forth between the shell halves, letting the white fall into the bowl, then drop the yolk into the large bowl. Keep the whites for something else, or discard them. Add 1 whole egg to the yolks.
- Make the filling. Add the pumpkin to the eggs and whisk until smooth. Add the condensed milk, 1 teaspoon cinnamon, 1/2 teaspoon ginger, 1/2 teaspoon salt, 1/4 teaspoon nutmeg and 1/8 teaspoon five-spice. Whisk until completely smooth and one even color, with no streaks of white condensed milk. It will be thick but pourable.
- Fill. Pour the filling into the shell. It should come close to the top of the crust but not over it. Tap the baking sheet on the counter a few times to bring air bubbles to the surface.
- Bake hot, then moderate. Bake 15 minutes at 425°F. Then, without opening the door, turn the oven down to 350°F and bake 30 to 40 minutes more.
- Test for doneness. From 30 minutes after lowering the heat, push a paring knife into the filling 1 inch in from the edge. If it comes out clean, the pie is done. If wet filling clings to it, bake 5 more minutes and test again. When done, the outer ring of filling looks set and slightly puffed and the very center still wobbles slightly when you nudge the pan, like set jelly, not like liquid. It firms up as it cools. Do not bake until the center is firm; an extra few minutes is what causes cracks.
- Watch the crust edge. If the rim of the crust turns dark brown before the filling is done, lay strips of foil loosely over just the rim for the rest of the bake.
- Cool completely. Set the pie on the rack and leave it until it is at room temperature all the way through: the bottom of the pan should feel cool, which takes a few hours. Do not slice it warm; the custard is still setting. Then cover it loosely with foil or plastic wrap and refrigerate.
- Serve cold or at room temperature, with whipped cream and a little extra nutmeg on top.
Getting it to Carson's
- Bake it the day before. The pie must be completely cool before covering, or condensation drips on the top.
- Carry it flat, still on the baking sheet or in a box, on the car floor rather than a seat. Keep it in the fridge until you leave and put it in Carson's fridge when you arrive.
- It needs nothing at Carson's: no oven, no microwave. Bring the whipped cream and keep it in the fridge.
- Leave it in its foil pan; there is no need to bring the pie plate back.
If something goes wrong
- The top cracked. It baked a little too long. It tastes the same; cover the cracks with whipped cream.
- The center is still liquid after 40 minutes at 350°F. Deep-dish shells hold more filling. Keep baking in 5-minute steps and use the knife test, not the clock.
- Filling overflowed. The shell was not deep-dish. Next time, stop pouring a little below the rim and bake any leftover filling in a small greased ovenproof dish alongside, checking it with the knife test.
- Bottom crust is soft. Expected with no pre-bake. Some reviewers pre-bake the shell first; if you want to, follow the box's directions for a baked (empty) shell, let it cool, then fill.
- It tastes mild. Some reviewers add a little more cinnamon or a pinch of ground cloves next time. Serve it with whipped cream, which softens the sweetness and carries the spice.
Changes from the original
- Written for a store-bought frozen 9-inch deep-dish shell rather than the homemade crust Chef John links. The shell is handled per its package and not pre-baked, which matches the recipe.
- The pie bakes on a rimmed baking sheet, and foil strips on the rim are added if the crust darkens early. Neither is in the recipe; both are practical additions for a thin foil pan, and the foil step comes from reviewers.
- Ground nutmeg is allowed in place of freshly grated.